Public Record Media

Public record research • Public interest publication Transparency litigation • Public affairs education

VA says probe continues regarding Minnesota clinics

By Mike Kaszuba

The U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) said that an investigation is continuing into Sterling Medical Associates Inc., a company that has already agreed to pay $1.85 million to resolve allegations that it filed false claims after it failed to schedule timely appointments for veterans at two Minnesota clinics.

The VA made the assertion in denying the appeal of a request for documents made by Public Record Media (PRM), a non-profit based in Saint Paul.

VA: Investigation remains ongoing

In a September 21st letter to PRM, the federal agency stated that “the investigation from which you requested records remains an open investigation” and that providing documents “could reasonably be expected to interfere with ongoing proceedings by revealing the scope of the investigation.”  The VA’s Office of Inspector General’s Office of Investigations, the letter added, “will close the investigation when they determine that law enforcement proceedings are complete.”

In its appeal, PRM stated that Sterling Medical Associates had agreed to the monetary settlement with the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) in March and that the action appeared to have effectively closed the case.

Though the Cincinnati-based company did not acknowledge liability as part of the settlement, the DOJ alleged that between July 2013 and August 2014 the company did not schedule patient appointments at the Hibbing, MN clinic in compliance with requirements and “changed veterans’ requested appointment dates to make appointment wait times appear shorter.”

Sterling had contract to operate VA clinics

The VA awarded Sterling Medical Associates a contract to operate its clinics in Hibbing and Ely, MN in March 2013. The DOJ said the contract was to follow VA requirements that routine appointments be scheduled within 14 calendar days of a veteran’s requested appointment date.

The DOJ added that the “claims resolved by the settlement are allegations only, and there has been no determination of liability.” In the settlement agreement, the DOJ also released the company “from any civil or administrative monetary claim”, including “the common law theories of breach of contract, payment by mistake, unjust enrichment, and fraud.”

The Sterling Medical Associates contract with the VA clinics had drawn earlier media scrutiny.

In 2014, the Minneapolis Star Tribune quoted company employees as saying they were ordered to falsify records.  The paper also reported that internal e-mails related to record keeping suggested that Sterling Medical Associates managers were concerned about failing to meet the 14-day appointment window and urged employees to alter appointment dates after the fact.

The newspaper added that the Minneapolis VA, which operated the Hibbing clinic, maintained at the time that it had a strong relationship with the company and that “there is no evidence of inappropriate scheduling practices at these clinics.”

Ongoing investigation revealed through PRM FOIA appeal

PRM had initially sought records in July regarding the case from both the VA and the DOJ. While the DOJ produced a nine-page settlement agreement with Sterling Medical Associates, the VA said in August that its records were being withheld under an exemption that allowed it to do so if releasing them might interfere with law enforcement proceedings.  The VA’s latest letter provided more details as to the federal agency’s reasoning.

In appealing the VA’s initial denial to produce documents in the case, PRM contended that “it appears unlikely that Sterling would have settled its civil claims if it reasonably expected to litigate other, criminal claims in the immediate future.  Thus, it seems that – in all likelihood – DOJ’s investigation of Sterling Medical Associates has terminated.”

But the VA, in denying the appeal, said the case against Sterling Medical Associates was not closed – and that the documents being requested were not public.

In its latest letter, the VA said that as long as law enforcement proceedings were continuing the agency was not obligated to release documents concerning the case.  “The courts have interpreted the term ‘law enforcement proceedings’ [to] include not only criminal actions, but civil actions and regulatory proceedings,” the VA stated.

“Agencies may protect records under [a federal exemption], if the records fall within the legal guidelines set by the courts,” the VA added. “Specifically, the courts have required agencies to determine, in order to claim this exemption, that disclosure of the records may reasonably cause an articulable harm to law enforcement proceedings.”

 

(Supporting documents for this article can be accessed by contacting Public Record Media at admin@publicrecordmedia.org , or at 651-556-1381)


Filter by Topic

  • All
  • 2016 election (3)
  • 2020 election (2)
  • Abortion (1)
  • Alan Page (3)
  • Amazon (5)
  • Anoka County (2)
  • BCA (2)
  • Barack Obama (3)
  • Bill McGuire (2)
  • Bob Dylan (1)
  • Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness (3)
  • COVID (4)
  • Cargill (2)
  • Chanhassen (1)
  • Check Topics (3)
  • Congress (1)
  • DEED (7)
  • Dakota Access Pipeline (2)
  • Donald Trump (17)
  • Drones (3)
  • Eagan (1)
  • Edward Snowden (1)
  • Espionage Act (1)
  • FBI (9)
  • Federal Aviation Administration (3)
  • Federal Communications Commision (1)
  • Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis (3)
  • Federal Transit Administration (1)
  • Financial Services Roundtable (1)
  • FoxConn (1)
  • George Floyd (4)
  • Glen Taylor (1)
  • Google (1)
  • Gov. Arne Carlson (1)
  • Gov. Mark Dayton (7)
  • Gov. Scott Walker (1)
  • Gov. Tim Pawlenty (1)
  • Gov. Tim Walz (3)
  • Greater MSP (7)
  • Health Partners (1)
  • Hennepin County (1)
  • Hennepin County Attorney's Office (1)
  • Hennepin County Sheriff's Office (6)
  • Hillary Clinton (2)
  • Huawei (1)
  • Hubbard family (1)
  • Immigration (3)
  • InfraGard (2)
  • J. Edgar Hoover (1)
  • Jamar Clark (1)
  • Jerry Kill (1)
  • Joan Gabel (1)
  • Joe Biden (4)
  • Justice Antonin Scalia (1)
  • KSTP-TV (1)
  • Kenneth Dahlberg (1)
  • Marv Davidov (2)
  • Medtronic (1)
  • Met Council (2)
  • Metro Transit (2)
  • Minneapolis (8)
  • Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey (3)
  • Minneapolis rally (2)
  • Minnesota (13)
  • Minnesota Attorney General (2)
  • Minnesota Council of Health Plans (1)
  • Minnesota Department of Health (1)
  • Minnesota Department of Human Services (1)
  • Minnesota Department of Natural Resources (1)
  • Minnesota Department of Transportation (3)
  • Minnesota Management and Budget (1)
  • Minnesota State Fair (1)
  • Minnesota State Patrol (1)
  • Minnesota United FC (3)
  • Minnesota Vikings (9)
  • Minnesota state auditor (1)
  • Myron Frans (1)
  • National Football League (3)
  • National Guard (1)
  • National Transportation Safety Board (1)
  • Neel Kashkari (4)
  • PJ Fleck (1)
  • Page Amendent (3)
  • Peter Smith (2)
  • Pohlad family (1)
  • PolyMet (2)
  • Prince (1)
  • Prinsburg (1)
  • Public Record Media (6)
  • Public Records (1)
  • Ramsey County Sheriff's Office (2)
  • Richard Painter (1)
  • Robert Mueller III (2)
  • Row The Boat (1)
  • Scott County (2)
  • Securian Financial (1)
  • Securities and Exchange Commission (1)
  • Sen. Rod Grams (1)
  • Sherburne County (1)
  • Sierra Nevada Corporation (1)
  • St. Louis Park (1)
  • St. Paul (8)
  • St. Paul Mayor Chris Coleman (1)
  • Sterling Medical Associates (1)
  • Stillwater Bridge (1)
  • Super Bowl (5)
  • TCF Bank Stadium (1)
  • Tesla (1)
  • Texas (1)
  • Third Precinct (1)
  • Twin Metals (2)
  • U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (1)
  • U.S. Marshal's Office (1)
  • U.S. Supreme Court (2)
  • US Bank (2)
  • US Bank Stadium (6)
  • US Bureau of Land Management (2)
  • US Department of Defense (5)
  • US Department of Justice (2)
  • US Forest Service (2)
  • United Health Group (1)
  • University of Minnesota (11)
  • Washington County (1)
  • Watergate (1)
  • Wayzata (1)
  • White Bear Lake (1)
  • Wisconsin (2)
  • Wisconsin TV station (1)
  • firearm background checks (1)
  • health management organizations (1)
  • homelessness (1)
  • ilhan omar (1)
  • non-disclosure agreement (1)
  • public records (10)